I ordered these because my 6 yo Shih Tzus love the beef and sweet potato treats. However, these are nothing like the soft, chewy beef and sweet potato. These were were hard as a brick. I cut them in small pieces , but the dogs wouldn’t eat them or swallowed whole. I even tried microwaving them to soften enough that the dogs could eat them. Unless you have a big dog with a strong jaw stick with the beef and sweet potato. My dogs liked the flavor, but I was afraid they would choke on them.